Skip to main content
TexansFor Financial ChoiceTexans For Financial Choice, home
All press articles

Jan 2026

A 10% credit card cap would make the affordability crisis worse

Originally published by Tampa Bay Times: read the original(opens in a new tab)

Two economists explain why.

By Michael A. Coon and Abigail R. Hall

Public sentiment in the United States is clear: Things are unaffordable. Between inflation, tariffs and a cooling economy, many Americans are feeling the pinch.

To address this issue, the president recently announced plans to “cap” or limit credit card interest rates at 10%, a significant decrease from U.S. average of just under 24%. On the surface, this seems like a reasonable way to help households reduce their monthly expenditures. In the wake of high inflation after the pandemic, many households turned to credit cards to make ends meet. U.S. household credit card debt has grown from $735 billion in 2021 to $1.1 trillion today.

At the same time, the Federal Reserve has raised interest rates to fight inflation. This matters because credit card rates fluctuate with the rates set by the Fed. Higher rates mean higher rates. Taken together, increased credit card debt and higher interest rates act as a one-two punch for many households.

To many, limiting credit card interest rates seems like a quick and easy way to relieve financial pressure on working families. Floridians carry some of the highest credit card debts in the country, with an average balance of over $9,100. Many would welcome the lower rates.

There’s just one major problem: This policy will backfire — spectacularly.

It is important to understand that there is no single universal interest rate for credit. Whether it is a credit card, auto loan, mortgage or any other loan, the interest rate an individual pays depends on the perceived risk of default the lender expects from that individual. The interest rate is based on numerous individual characteristics (income, payment history, etc.) and measured by the borrower’s credit score.

Borrowers with high credit scores (low risk) pay lower interest rates than those with low credit scores (high risk). If you see a commercial for a car dealer offering zero percent interest on a new car, you will notice the fine print that says, “only for well-qualified borrowers.”

Although it may seem unfair to charge those with great credit (most likely wealthier borrowers) lower rates than those with bad credit (most likely poorer borrowers), the reality is that many poorer borrows would not get credit at all at lower rates.

Imagine, for example, you own a bank. Under the president’s proposal, you couldn’t charge more than 10% on a credit card. Would you give a card to someone with a 30% chance of default?

Of course not. Neither would any other bank.

So, where would those with a risky credit profile go if they needed to cover an immediate expense? Many turn to a payday lender, borrowing against their future income. While these companies provide a valuable service, it comes at a steep price.

Rather than charging interest in the same way as a typical credit card, payday lenders often charge a one-time “borrower fee.” For example, someone wishing to borrow $500 for a month might pay a $50 fee.

If this is a one-time need, paying an extra $50 to prevent getting the lights shut off or your car repossessed might seem like a great deal. In practice, however, many low-income households the use payday lenders find themselves in a “debt trap.” Strapped for cash to begin with (hence the need for the initial loan), they may not have any additional cushion come next payday when they must pay their regular bills and the payday loan.

So what do they do? They borrow again — and incur another $50 fee.

As this cycle continues, borrowers wind up paying hundreds, sometimes thousands, in fees over the course of a year. If one calculates the annual percentage rate, a borrower could easily be paying the equivalent of a 60% interest rate. Some studies have put the average effective annualized interest rate for payday loans at around 400%.

If credit card interest rates were capped, this would harm the very people such a policy aims to help. Not only would it fail to help borrowers, it would paradoxically make things less affordable. Lenders would only issue new credit cards to people with stellar credit. Those with fair credit would likely see their credit limits fall. And those at the bottom of the credit ladder? Shut out completely or pushed toward payday loans or black-market lending.

If the president were truly serious about helping consumers with affordability, he would do well to eliminate the tariffs he’s imposed his first year in office, which have served to increase the price of goods and services and led to a sluggish economy. The current proposal tries to fix the problems created by the previous policy by doubling down on bad economics.

Michael A. Coon and Abigail R. Hall are associate professors of economics at the University of Tampa

This article was originally published by Tampa Bay Times and is reproduced here for reference. View the original(opens in a new tab)

Make Sure Your Voice Is Heard In Austin

TAKE ACTION NOW